6:46am8:48pm EDT
Feels like: 77°F
Wind: 6mph NNW
Humidity: 54%
Pressure: 29.94"Hg
UV index: 6

Best Pizza in Greater Kalamazoo

Posted on March 5th, 2014
best pizza kalamazoo

“#Glutenfree #pizza from #Erbellis. Yum! #getinmybelly #Michigan #puremichigan” – @emmayoungdale on Instagram

Kayla Kiley

You can find Kayla Kiley wrapping up in the unparalleled beauty of Michigan summers, grooving to local live music, sipping on the inventive craft-beer scene, joining foodie tours, oil painting, ballroom dancing, and simply exploring the world around her.

Kalamazoo, Mich. — If you’re like me, you’re in a very committed relationship with pizza.

In fact, I love it with every pizza my heart. 😉

But with more than 450 Kalamazoo County restaurants to choose from — many of which serve pizza — how do you know which place offers the best pie?

That’s why we turned to our friends on social media! Our Facebook fans and Twitter and Instagram followers recommended their favorite saucy hot spots — some even suggested what to order while you’re there:

Erbelli’s (9 votes):
6214 Stadium Drive, Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 375-0408
8342 Portage Road, Portage, MI | 269-327-0200

  • “Parmesan garlic chicken wings, Erbbie bread, baked ziti and any pizza at Erbelli’s” – Anna Versalle
  • “@ErbellisPizza on Stadium is by far my favorite. The Chicken Carbonara pizza is the go-to choice, fresh Romano cheese makes it perfect”- @BradGuldemond
best pizza kalamazoo

“Martini’s is my favorite (obviously)! You have to try the Pepperoni and Banana Pepper or Sausage and Mushroom pizzas if you haven’t yet. Their subs are also amazing.” – @lukelarsson on Instagram

Martini’s Pizza (9 votes):
832 S. Westnedge Ave., Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 388-8883

  • “I love Martini’s pizza & salad.” – Jerolyn Selkirk
  • “Martinis is my favorite!! I always order a slice of cheese & small house salad, but I also love their subs and many entrees. Highly recommend it in general!” – @kaitlinrosemusic
  • “Martini’s is my favorite(obviously)! You have to try the Pepperoni and Banana Pepper or Sausage and Mushroom pizzas if you haven’t yet. Their subs are also amazing.” – @lukelarsson
  • “I’d probably put Maritini’s on top due mostly to the sauce and the cheese and Erbelli’s second. I’d also give Shakespeares stone oven pizza some love, and a thumbs up to Chicago Style as well…” – Andy Miller
best pizza kalamazoo

“Super Bowl food… #foodporn #yum #delicious #bilbos #kzoo #local #pizza” – unconventionalgrrrl

Bilbo’s Pizza in a Pan (4 votes)
3307 Stadium Drive, Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 382-5544
6202 S. Westnedge Ave., Portage, MI | (269) 323-8855

  • “Bilbo’s, hands down. Amazing salad and wonderful pizza.” – Kiersten Novak

Franco’s Italian Pizzeria (3 votes)
8016 S. Westnedge Ave., Portage, MI | (269) 327-3467

Pizza King (3 votes)
5236 Portage Road, Portage, MI| (269) 381-8692

  • “Pizza King on Portage Rd has been the family favorite for over 30 yrs.” – Michelle Copenhaver

Bimbo’s Pizza (2 votes)
338 E. Michigan Ave., Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 349-3134

Bruno’s Pizza (2 votes; no website)
1528 W. Michigan Ave., Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 349-3229

Chicago Style Pizza (2 votes)
10420 Portage Road, Portage, MI | (269) 323-0807

  • “Hands-down best. …If you’re craving pizza Chicago Styles Deep Dish with sausage and olives.” – Kim Dahill Bragg
  • “I would say Chicago style as my #1 choice, the deep dish pepperoni.” – Robin Johnson

Jaspare’s Pizza and Fine Italian Food (2 votes)
6050 Gull Road, Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 382-2900
3262 Stadium Drive, Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 544-1100
5965 S. Sprinkle Road, Portage, MI | (269) 388-4810
111 S. Main St., Vicksburg, MI | (269) 649-3975

Papa Pete’s Pizza (2 votes)
502 S. Burdick St., Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 388-2196

  • “Papa Pete’s is the best kept secret. Definitely get the pizza.” – Erik Rebecca Watkins
  • “If you like bimbos you’ve gotta try #Papapetespizza or #bennuccis” – @SrGueroLoco

Bennucci’s Chicago Oven & Grill (1 vote)
3717 E Cork St. Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 385-2222

Fricano’s of Alamo (1 vote):
7454 N. 6th St., Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 342-0808

  • “Sausage and mushroom” – Linda West

Geno’s Pizza (1 vote):
113 N Riverview Drive, Kalamazoo | 269.345.7266

  • “Large with pepperoni, mushroon, bacon, onion, and green pepper. You can get the XL 1-topping PLUS breadsticks for $9.99 any day. Awesome deal!” – Robin Johnson

Gonzo’s Biggdogg Brewing (1 vote):
140 S. Westnedge Ave. | (269) 382-2739

  • “Gonzo’s Biggdogg Brewing Pizza is delicious!!! While you’re there you must try the poutine, it is amazing as is the beer!!! You won’t be disappointed!” – Elaine G. Amaya-Martin

Jet’s Pizza (1 vote)
3321 Stadium Drive, Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 372-2600
5151 Gull Road, Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 488-2000
631 Romence Road, Kalamazoo, MI | (269) 329-0528

  • “When I’m short on time.” – @BradGuldemond

Didn’t get to cast your vote? Let us know in the comments!

Click here for more cool things to do in Kalamazoo!
Click here for a list of restaurants in Kalamazoo!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *